Matthew Knies is drawing real trade interest this offseason, and as of Wednesday the Toronto Maple Leafs hadn't decided what to do about it.
That's the word from insider Marco D'Amico, who reported that Knies is "very much in play at this point" while noting the Leafs are "not assured to move him."
Not assured. That phrase is doing a lot of work.
It means there's a real conversation happening inside the organization. It means teams are calling. It means Toronto is at least entertaining the idea of moving their 23-year-old left wing.
The stakes aren't minor. Knies carries a $7.75 million cap hit and posted 66 points in 79 games this season, 23 goals and 43 assists.
He went minus-30 on the year. That number matters when you look at what was happening around him.
Toronto finished 32-36-14, ranked 28th in the league. The team allowed 299 goals, a -46 goal differential. The Leafs lost their last seven straight.
So the minus-30 isn't entirely on Knies. This team was a sieve from November on.
Toronto's rebuild dilemma: move Knies or build around him?
Still, his last five games tell a more uncomfortable story: held scoreless, just two assists, went minus-8 across that stretch.
For a player at $7.75 million, you need that top-six production to show up when the season is on the line. It didn't.
The Leafs are clearly entering some kind of transition. A 28th-place finish and a seven-game losing skid to close the year demands answers.
Here's the uncomfortable part for Toronto fans. The choices aren't clean.
Knies is young, he can skate, and 66 points at 23 isn't nothing. Selling low on a winger that age, coming off a team-wide disaster of a season, is the kind of move that haunts a front office for years.
On the other hand, keeping a $7.75 million forward on a team that just gave up 299 goals isn't a solution either. It's just expensive mediocrity with a younger face.
Think of it like renovating a house with a cracked foundation. You can't just repaint the kitchen and call it a rebuild.
The Leafs have Auston Matthews at $13.25 million and William Nylander at $11.5 million locked in. They don't have room to carry question marks at that price point elsewhere on the roster.
D'Amico's "talks intensifying" doesn't mean a deal is imminent. But it means the phone is ringing, and Toronto is picking up.
-
Whether they hold or deal, this decision is going to define what direction this franchise actually wants to go. And right now, they don't seem to know yet.
Should the Leafs trade Matthew Knies this offseason?
Also read on Markerzone.com:
The Winnipeg Jets are moving on from star goaltender Connor Hellebuyck: Trade talks intensify with one team
