Ryan Poehling's disputed playoff winner is back under the microscope, giving Mike Babcock's Oilers an old controversy to hear about again.
A viral Oilers post has revived the debate from Game 4 against the Anaheim Ducks, months after Edmonton's season was pushed to the brink by one of the playoffs' strangest reviews.
Poehling ended the game 2:29 into overtime when the puck slipped through Tristan Jarry and came to rest near the goal line before play was stopped.
The officials initially did not award a goal. After discussing the play, they ruled it a goal, shifting the review standard toward finding evidence that the puck had not completely crossed.
The resurfaced clip shows the puck disappearing beneath Jarry's skate as Jake Walman reaches into the crease, with no clean daylight visible between the puck and goal line.
The sequence can be watched here:
-
And that tight camera angle is exactly why the debate has returned.
Oilers fans still question the defining call that Ryan Poehling scored
The ruling gave Anaheim a 4-3 victory and sent Edmonton home facing a 3-1 series deficit, turning one difficult replay into a season-threatening moment.
Jarry had made 34 saves in his first start of those playoffs, only to have the night end with officials gathered around a puck nobody watching the standard angles could easily locate.
Connor McDavid also questioned the sequence afterward, while Edmonton's frustration centered less on whether the puck might have crossed and more on whether the available pictures proved it.
That distinction is why the clip still has legs. A likely goal and a conclusively proven goal aren't always viewed as the same thing when a playoff game ends on the ruling.
Edmonton survived its next elimination game, but Anaheim eventually closed the series in Game 6. The disputed winner remains tied to the moment the Oilers lost control of the matchup.
Now the conversation has followed the organization into a different coaching chapter, with Babcock behind the bench and no chance to change what happened that night.
What remains is an uncomfortable question for Oilers fans: if the same replay surfaced in another overtime playoff game, would everyone agree there was enough evidence to decide a season?
Did officials have enough proof to award Ryan Poehling's goal?
Also read on Markerzone.com:
Maple Leafs forward left unable to walk this summer after offseason surgery turns terrible
