SEARCH


Per Dreger, a huge trade target just hit the market and teams are calling like crazy

PUBLICATION
Jonathan Ouimet
May 21, 2026  (10:57 PM)
SHARE THIS STORY

May 4, 2026; Toronto, Ontario, CANADA; Toronto Maple Leafs general manager John Chayka speaks to the media during an introductory news conference at Real Sports Bar and Grill.
Photo credit: Dan Hamilton-Imagn Images

Darren Dreger dropped a sentence Friday that makes the Maple Leafs offseason look messier than it already did.

According to Dreger, multiple teams around the league are saying Leafs GM John Chayka's stance on whether Matthew Knies is actually available changes from one day to the next.

That's not the kind of read rival front offices invent. They share notes. If two teams are saying the same thing, it's already a pattern.

Dreger framed it directly. Chayka is entitled to his view. But the back-and-forth signal is what teams are noticing while they prep their summer boards.

A GM who can't commit to a position on his most coveted young winger isn't running a quiet rebuild. He's running an audition.

Why the Matthew Knies indecision says more than the trade itself

Knies is 23, signed at $7.75 million, and put up 66 points in 79 games this season. The ceiling is real. So is the floor that hit -30 along the way.

That's a player worth thinking twice about. The problem isn't Chayka pausing. The problem is Chayka pausing publicly, on different days, in front of the same teams.

The Chris Johnston report from Tuesday already had Toronto telling other clubs they'd discuss anyone except Auston Matthews. Knies fell into the "discuss" pile by default.

Now Dreger's reporting adds the wrinkle. Chayka is in that pile on Monday, out of it on Tuesday, somewhere in between by Wednesday.

Friday's news lands in a building that just fired Craig Berube. The bench is open. The roster is open. The GM's positions, apparently, are open too.

That's a lot of doors swinging at once in a hockey market that punishes hesitation harder than anywhere in the league.

Knies finished the year ice cold. Just 2 points and a -8 in his last 5 games as Toronto closed the schedule at 32-36-14 for 78 points and 28th overall.

A buyer would point at those last 5 games to drive the price down. A seller would point at the 66-point year to push it up. Both arguments need a GM willing to plant his flag.

Auston Matthews already told the building, through The Fourth Period reporting, that he wants to see the plan. Friday's Dreger report just made the plan harder to draw.

If Chayka can't decide whether Knies is in or out, what does he tell Matthews when the captain walks into his office in July?