SEARCH


A new favorite for the Oilers' next goalie is emerging and fans hate the idea

PUBLICATION
Vincent Carbonneau
May 23, 2026  (3:11 PM)
SHARE THIS STORY

Mar 12, 2026; Dallas, Texas, USA; A view of the logo on the jersey of Edmonton Oilers goaltender Tristan Jarry (35) during the game between the Stars and the Oilers at the American Airlines Center.
Photo credit: Jerome Miron-Imagn Images

Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen and Lindy Ruff just got pulled into Edmonton's summer goalie problem.

Jeff Marek's comment was enough to get people talking fast.

The idea is that maybe there is something between the Oilers and the Sabres around Luukkonen.

On the surface, you get why Edmonton would look. The Oilers still do not have a real answer in net, and every summer rumor around them ends up circling back to the same hole.

That does not mean Luukkonen is the answer.

If this is the swing Stan Bowman is thinking about, it is fair to ask what exactly changes for Edmonton.

Because the biggest complaint around the Oilers has not gone anywhere. They still need a goalie who can settle a series, not just start one.

And Luukkonen did not exactly build that kind of trust in the playoffs against Montreal.

He had rough moments in that series, and that is the part Edmonton should be staring at.

Jeff Marek: Maybe there's something with the Oilers...around [Sabres' goalie] Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen - Daily Faceoff Live (5/19)

Oilers fans are panicking after a shocking new goalie favorite emerged

That is what makes this rumor feel shaky.

If the Oilers bring in Luukkonen and he gives them the same kind of uneven playoff goaltending Buffalo just lived through, then Edmonton is right back where it started.

Same stress.

Same noise.

Same question every time the puck gets near the crease.

That is not a small issue on this team.

Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl are not at the stage where the organization can keep experimenting with goalies who still feel like a debate. Edmonton needs a real answer, or at least something a lot closer to one.

Luukkonen has talent. Nobody is denying that.

But if the sales pitch is basically that he might be better in a new setting, that is not strong enough for a team with this much pressure on it.

The Oilers have lived on that kind of hope before.

It usually ends the same way.

That is why this rumor should make fans uneasy, not excited. Luukkonen may be a name worth asking about. He is not the kind of name that should make Edmonton feel like the crease is fixed.

And if that is the solution, then the Oilers still have the same problem they had before.

Just with a different mask in the net.