Kirby Dach enters camp with a real chance to become Martin St-Louis' second-line centre for the Montreal Canadiens.
That possibility has sparked a sharp debate among fans, with some already writing Dach out of the club's long-term plans.
The reaction feels premature. Montreal still needs size, puck protection and playmaking behind its top centre, and Dach offers all 3 when his game is settled.
One supporter argued that Dach should open the season at 2C unless the Canadiens complete a trade. Given the current roster, that projection carries weight.
The role wouldn't be a reward for past promise. Dach would need to earn it through camp, hold his own in the faceoff circle and bring steady offensive output.
Montreal can explore outside upgrades, but no confirmed move has removed Dach from the picture. For now, he remains one of St-Louis' clearest internal options.
" Crazy seeing so many Habs fans rooting for Kirby Dach's downfall rn. Hot take, he's my 2C going into the season (barring a trade) "
-
Major acquisition confirmed for Kent Hughes as Kirby Dach's role changes in Montreal
The Canadiens signed Dach to a one-year contract worth $3,600,000, creating a season built around results rather than long-term guarantees.
That structure puts pressure on both sides. Montreal gets another evaluation window, while Dach gets a direct opportunity to rebuild his value and secure a larger role.
His best route is through the middle. Playing centre would place him around the puck more often and let him use his frame to protect possession below the circles.
It would also give St-Louis more freedom with his wingers. A productive Dach could support a scoring line without forcing Montreal to break apart combinations elsewhere.
The fan frustration comes from expectations that haven't been met consistently. But rooting for a player's downfall does nothing to improve the roster or solve the second-line question.
Dach doesn't need sympathy. He needs strong camp practices, clean decisions through the neutral zone and enough pace to keep his line connected.
A trade could still alter the depth chart before puck drop. Until one happens, dismissing Dach ignores the opportunity directly in front of him.
Montreal's best outcome is simple: Dach stays healthy, wins the job and gives St-Louis a dependable second-line centre without forcing management into an expensive move.
Should Kirby Dach begin the season as Montreal's second-line centre?
Also read on Markerzone.com:
Mike Babcock already has a major issue to deal with after taking the job
